Total Rating: 
October 7, 2017
October 27, 2017
December 30, 2017
New York
New York
William Franzblau
Theater Type: 
St. Luke's Theater
Theater Address: 
308 West 46 Street
Running Time: 
90 min
Book: Dorothy Marcic
Tamara Kangas Erickson

What songs make up the soundtrack of your life? Do the hits of the last century reflect the moods of the times and attitude towards women? That was the question writer Dorothy Marcic sought to answer in her book “Respect,” the basis for the new Off-Broadway show This One’s For The Girls. Marcic examined the Top 40 songs sung by women, determining that the music showed the change of women’s attitudes from co-dependency to independent.

The show features an ensemble of four women performers. Jana Robbins plays Janet, a writer-researcher who narrates the history of women from the time of the suffragettes to present-day as she tells the story of the women in her life. Among them are women who have been abused by husbands, women who were independent, and others who were housewives.

Many of the songs are presented as snippets or as musical mash-ups. A few songs become stories, giving each of the other three female performers opportunities to showcase their skills.

Haley Swindal is adorable singing Vikki Carr’s hit “It Must Be Him.” She plays a young woman agonizing over the phone call that doesn’t come. She also is a Betty Boop character when she sings, “I Want To Be Loved By You.” Traci Bair is flirtatious and coquettish as she sings “Diamonds Are A Girl’s Best Friend.” The play tells of sexy girls like Marilyn Monroe who morphed into Anna Nicolle Smith into the Kardashians. Anessa Folds brings down the house with her version of Billie Holiday songs and she later plays Rosa Parks.

Besides the wonderfully familiar music (many songs here track the story of my own life), the play makes effective use of photos flashed on a screen over the stage. As the ladies sing, we find ourselves identifying the famous people. When the performers offerJoanie Sommers’ “Johnny Get Angry,” we see pictures of Johnny Carson, Johnny Cash, and Johnny Mathis. During “Sweet-Talking Guy,” photos flash of Bill Cosby, OJ Simpson, Bill Clinton, and Hugh Hefner. Of course, we see pictures of iconic women, as well.

The show moves quickly and is quite entertaining. My colleague noted that it was slower in the beginning when she didn’t recognize some of the music. The show picked up when music became familiar. For many, the earlier music of the suffragette times and WWII might not resonate but the history will: women who worked in factories lost their jobs when the men returned. There’s little costuming in the musical but there is one cute bit when the Rosie the Riveter denim jackets convert into aprons.

As the senior member of the cast, Robbins doesn’t sing as much as the others, and her vibrato can be too pronounced. The play opens with “Janet” explaining about the man who left her two years earlier and how she has been trying to pick up the pieces. When he finally calls, she blows him off. (Her part obviously registers with some of the audience who cheer for her.)

The musical covers all the familiar songs and knows how to hit all the right buttons, including a segment on Rosa Parks (though including a part of Martin Luther King Jr.’s speech during that segment feels unnecessary).

What would a woman’s show be without anthems like “I Am Woman” and “Respect?” We expect to hear them, and the show does not disappoint. This One’s for the Girls is a show written about women for women. It makes for a great girls’ night out.

Traci Bair, Aneesa Folds, Jana Robbins, Haley Swindal
Music Dir: Zachary Ryan. Costumes; Cynthia Nordstrom
Elyse Trevers
Date Reviewed: 
October 2017